The candidate possesses an exceptional professional background, an outstanding publication record and valuable international experience. The researcher’s career path aligns seamlessly with the proposed project, which is innovative, ambitious, timely, and well-structured. The project's goal — to connect solid-state physics and quantum information by investigating the use of magnons as quantum information carriers — presents an intriguing alternative to photons for near-device quantum communication. The theoretical and computational methodologies proposed are advanced and the proposed work could generate a significant impact on the field. Additionally, key impurity effects are incorporated, and the choice of host institution is also ideal.

Nevertheless, concerns regarding the project's feasibility and the potentially insufficient coupling strength exist, despite efforts to mitigate them with supporting evidence. Furthermore, the proposal is essentially based on theory, without much consideration for technological aspects, which could represent a handicap in this field. Therefore, the inclusion of experimental aspects would be valuable both for the project and the applicant, as a more hands-on approach could enhance the impact and applicability. However, the role of the experimental component in the proposed project is not clearly defined. Lastly, the vision document could be further developed and the motivation for the proposal could be stronger.
